Where to stay in Stella Maris means adjusting expectations to the scale of this small settlement on the northern end of Long Island in the Bahamas: this is honestly a modest resort-settlement destination rather than a place with a deep range of lodging tiers, and travelers should plan around that reality. Most visitors base themselves in or near Stella Maris itself, within reach of the settlement's small commercial center, or slightly further north toward Cape Santa Maria, an area known for one of the more striking beaches on Long Island and a genuine draw for travelers choosing this part of the island over the busier south. Lodging here is limited in number, spanning simple guesthouses through to a small number of more resort-style properties, without the broader luxury tier found on more developed Bahamian islands, so travelers should expect comfortable, low-key accommodation rather than an extensive shopping-around process. Given how few rooms exist across the whole settlement, booking well ahead matters more here than the island's quiet reputation might suggest, particularly around the winter high season when North American travelers seeking sun are most active, and last-minute availability can be genuinely scarce rather than merely tight. Long Island's remoteness means onward transport, whether a short domestic flight or a mailboat connection from Nassau, should be planned and confirmed alongside lodging rather than as an afterthought, since schedules here are less frequent than on the more connected islands. Cash and card are both used at the settlement's properties, though carrying Bahamian or US dollars as backup remains sensible given the small scale of local commerce. The Bahamas drives on the left, worth knowing for travelers renting a vehicle to explore Cape Santa Maria and the rest of Long Island beyond Stella Maris itself, and hurricane-season timing, roughly June through November, is worth weighing against the calmer, more reliable winter and spring months when booking.
We earn from qualifying purchases. Some links are affiliate — full disclosure.
Cross-trip essentials
Plan the rest of your trip
Vetted partners across the essentials. Bookings fulfilled by partner — Aurum earns commission on completed bookings, at no extra cost to you.
Need a ride?
Pre-book an airport transfer
Door-to-door private transfers in 100+ countries. Fixed prices, vetted drivers, instant confirmation.
Search transfers →Before your flight
Book an airport lounge
Skip the gate-area chaos. Hot food, fast Wi-Fi, real seating — at most major airports worldwide.
Browse lounges →Stay connected abroad
Pick an eSIM for your trip
Instant data on landing — no roaming charges, no SIM swap. Activates the moment you switch on your phone.
Browse eSIMs →